Uprootmap
New York vs Lancaster
New York and Lancaster
Photo: Randolph Carney / Wikimedia, CC BY-SA 3.0
Assumed income $83,730, same in both cities. Example, until you change it.
Other cities
So you know: homicide deaths in Lancaster are under the US rate in this release, 2.2 versus 6.5 per 100,000. CDC via County Health Rankings, CDC NVSS 2017–2023 (CHR 2025 release).
Why people look at New York to Lancaster
In 2022-2023, 492 households filed a move from New York to Lancaster (about 807 people, average adjusted gross income $74,622). 183 households went the other way. Source: IRS migration.
A one-bedroom asking rent is about $3,018 in New York and $1,217 in Lancaster. New York has a state tax on wages. Lancaster has a state tax on wages. Local pay in Lancaster is 95% of the national level for the same work, against 119% in New York.
Lancaster averages 194 sunny days, with July highs around 87°F and January nights around 30°F. New York is 224 sunny days, 85°F in July, 27°F in January. Commutes average 24 minutes in Lancaster and 38 in New York.
These figures are projections built from available public data. Conditions change, and the numbers may not reflect current prices, taxes, or immigration rules. Check official sources before you make decisions.
Who already made this move
In 2022-2023, 492 households moved New York → Lancaster (about 807 people, average AGI $74,622). 183 households went the other way.
Source: IRS SOI county-to-county migration. Not a moving company; not a recommendation.
The monthly number is take-home pay minus rent and the other bills. The gap between New York and Lancaster changes with the job, remote or local pay, and bedrooms. How we figure this.
What the move itself costs
About 165 road miles, 1 bedroom. Typical ranges, not quotes.
- Full-service mover
- $1,850–$3,500
- Container or pod
- $1,250–$2,350
- Rent a truck
- $500–$900
Explore more
Dig into Lancaster
Questions
Is Lancaster cheaper than New York after tax and rent?
Yes. Lancaster leaves about $2,251 more a month, so the cost of living is lower there for this household. A one-bedroom is about $3,018 in New York and $1,217 in Lancaster.
Does Lancaster have state income tax?
Lancaster is in Pennsylvania, which taxes wage income, plus a local wage tax of 1.00%.
Did people actually move from New York to Lancaster?
Yes, when the IRS published that flow. The count and their average income are on this page. Leftover prices the same household in both cities.